David Hyde Pierce won a Tony for playing Cioffi, but Robert Newman betters him… Cioffi is a character who must show star-struck giddiness. Newman — a tall, handsome daytime TV matinee idol from “The Guiding Light” – can nevertheless play against type and show how rabid a fan Cioffi is. Newman turns out to be an excellent song and dance man, too, especially in “A Tough Act to Follow,” which he fetchingly does with Amanda Rose.
-Peter Filichia/For The Star-Ledger
Newman navigates Joann M. Hunter’s complicated choreography with ease, and his voice is easy on the ears, too. Very funny as a wannabe director, he aptly communicates the loneliness of a single guy in “Coffee Shop Nights.”
-NJ Arts Maven
Newman is excellent as a Boston detective, Lt. Frank Cioffi
–Rick Busciglio – Examiner.com
Newman and Zimmer are born song-and-dance performers
-Stuart Duncan – newjerseynewsroom.com